Off-B'way Review: Midnight; The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Todrick Hall and Jeremy Beloate
in Midnight.
Credit: Valerie Terranova

You have to admire Todrick Hall’s ambition. The YouTube star and veteran of five Broadway shows and several reality TV programs has the rare distinction of directing, choreographing, writing the book, music, and lyrics, producing and playing the lead role in a new Off-Broadway musical Midnight. Just getting an original show with a cast of 20 up and running is a difficult feat in today’s challenging theatrical economy and Hall deserves full marks for that. However, the production itself could have benefitted for at least one more set of eyes and a red pencil. Clocking in at close to three hours, this musical fantasy on race relations and suppressed gay love is too long, monotonous and self-indulgent. There are impactful and well-performed individual moments, but they are drowned in a sea of excess.

Hall’s premise is intriguing and the opening number sets the stage for a promising evening. A huge clock is suspended above the stage (Morgan Large designed the imaginative set) as well as several mannequins sporting Beck Jones’ gorgeous and elaborate costumes. The cast consisting of an equal number of white and African-American performers enters in rehearsal clothes, the mannequins descend, and the actors sing of assuming identities as they don Civil War-era garb defining their roles along racial lines. 

The subsequent story follows a slave named Rail (Hall)—his monicker derives from his birth near train tracks—and his illicit same-sex affair with the white landowner and master Richard (The Voice finalist Jeremy Beloate). Their clandestine trysts occur at the titular hour, thus the ominous timepiece dominating the action. Hall’s direction moves the action along swiftly and engagingly (aided greatly by Jake DeGroot’s dynamic lighting) and many of Hall’s songs are soaring and effective, but the characters act as if it’s 2026 instead of 1862. Would black slaves really serve their white enslavers a dead mouse on top of the dessert? (The move was probably inspired by Octavia Spencer’s character’s hilarious act of gastronomic revenge against her white employer in The Help.)  Would a white Southern landowner really encourage black slaves and white workers to treat each other as equals while the Civil War raged? 

B'way Update: Jonathan Groff and Tom Hanks Return

Jonathan Groff

Tony winner Jonathan Groff and Oscar winner Tom Hanks will return to Broadway later this season, Groff in a new solo play The Amish Project and Hanks in a transfer of This World of Tomorrow, a play he co-wrote which previously played The Shed Off-Broadway.

Groff (Merrily We Roll Along, Just in Time) will take the stage alone in Jessica Dickey's The Amish Project at the Broadhurst Theater with performances beginning Feb. 10, 2027. Sarna Lapine (Sunday in the Park with George) directs. The play is inspired by a 2006 school shooting which occurred in a small Pennsylvania town near where Groff grew up.

The Amish Project debuted at the New York International Fringe Festival and was developed at the Cherry Lane Theatre before premiering Off-Broadway at the Rattlestick Playwrights Theater in 2009. It has since become Jessica Dickey’s most-produced play, with productions at the Guthrie Theater (Minneapolis), Milwaukee Rep, American Theater Company (Chicago) and City Theatre (Pittsburgh), among others at theaters around the world.

“20 years ago this month, an unimaginable tragedy happened in a one room Amish schoolhouse in Lancaster, Pennsylvania and Jessica Dickey wrote an astounding work of art in response," Groff said in a statement. "Sarna Lapine sent me The Amish Project last year and I was floored by the urgency and potent poetry of Jessica’s writing as she dives headfirst into the many aftershocks of this horrific event and explores the idea that sometimes the most radical human act is forgiveness. I am profoundly grateful to be bringing Jessica’s play to Broadway alongside Sarna and this incredible team.”

Kelli O'Hara and Tom Hanks in
This World of Tomorrow.
Credit: Marc J. Franklin

Tom Hanks will join Tony winner Kelli O'Hara in a Broadway transfer of This World of Tomorrow which he co-wrote with James Glossman, scheduled for fall 2027 at a Shubert theater TBA. This will be the first time Hanks has appeared on Broadway since Nora Ephron's Lucky Guy in 2014. The play previously played The Shed Off-Broadway in 2025. Based on a short story from Hanks' collection Uncommon Type, World of Tomorrow is a sci-fi tale about a scientist from the late 21st century who travel back in time to the the World's Fair of 1939 where he meets and falls in love with a woman named Carmen (O'Hara, reprising her Off-Broadway role). Tony winner Kenny Leon returns to direct.

Book Review: Theo of Golden

(Ordered from Amazon for about $10): The third book for my online book club. I knew I was in trouble in the first few pages when a young woman gives her life story to a complete stranger who has sent her a letter promising to gift her with a portrait. By the end of the book, I thought I was getting diabetes. The premise is straight out of a Hallmark card. A mysterious, wealthy old man (Theo of the title) shows up in a small Georgia town called Golden. He happens upon a coffee shop with portraits of the customers on the wall. He decides to buy the pictures one by one and present them to the subjects cause he's such a saintly fellow. Of course, each giftee has their own fascinating life story which they spill to Theo upon the bestowal. The nice people are so nice and the mean people are so mean, it made my teeth ache. There is a final twist which explains Theo's altruistic actions, but it's not believable.

Levi is an attorney and judge and this is his first novel. Good for him for getting it published and making it into a best-seller. But it's a predictable, easy, unchallenging read. A box of feel-good chocolates, nowhere near real life.  

I just read Tom Hanks is planning to star in the movie version. How appropriate, another Forrest Gump role.

B'way Review: Other Desert Cities

Allison Janney and Julia Louis-Dreyfus in
Other Desert Cities.
Credit: Emilio Madrid

When Jon Robin Baitz’s incisively-written Other Desert Cities opened at Lincoln Center’s Off-Broadway Mitzi Newhouse Theater in 2011 and then transferred to Broadway later the same year in Joe Mantello’s sensitive production, it was praised as an even-handed yet scathing examination of the state of our polarized nation. Each of the members of the politically and emotionally divided Wyeth family, a powerful clan with influential government, show business and literary connections, was seen as a fully-drawn, three-dimensional human being, not a representative of a particular point of view along the ideological spectrum.

The current Broadway revival at the Hudson is just as indicative of a fraught nation, even more so as the battle lines between left and right are more deeply and seemingly permanently drawn in Trump’s America. John Benjamin Hickey’s polished staging lands the laughs and heartbreaking moments solidly, but the acting choices made by the all-star cast have thrown the balance slightly off. 

Baitz’s story remains compelling. Over Christmas week 2004, the Wyeths reunite at the palatial Palm Springs home of parents Lyman and Polly (Scott Pask designed the gorgeous set.) Mom and Dad are a power couple in elite GOP circles. Lyman’s an ex-movie star and ambassador (possibly based on John Gavin) and Polly had a run as a Hollywood screenwriter of fluffy comedies with her liberal sister Silda, now a broke, recovering alcoholic living with her sister and brother-in-law. Daughter Brooke, a writer recently emerging from a devastating depression, and son Trip, a producer of a hit TV reality show, are visiting. The catalyst for the drama is Brooke’s about-to-be-published memoir in which she focuses on the family’s deepest wound. At the height of the Vietnam War, eldest son Henry was involved in a radical underground group which set off a bomb at a recruiting station, resulting in the death of a janitor and Henry’s subsequent suicide.

Lily Rabe, Joe Keery, and Julia Louis-Dreyfus
in Other Desert Cities.
Credit: Emilio Madrid

B'way/Off-B'way Update: Warriors Cast and Tilda Swinton

Amber Gray, Jasmine Cephas Jones and
Casey Likes will star in Warriors.

Warriors, the new musical by Lin-Manuel Miranda and Eisa Davis based on the 1979 cult film has announced its main cast and dates. Previews begin on March 9 at the Lunt-Fontanne prior to an April 8 opening. In this adaptation, the film's all-male Warriors street gang will be all-female. The cast will include Jaci Calderon, Aneesa Folds, Amber Gray (The Rocky Horror Show, Hadestown), Julia Harriman, Gizel Jiminez, Jasmine Cephas Jones (Hamilton), Kenita R. Miller (for colored girls), Sasha Allen (Hair), Casey Likes (Back to the Future, Heathers) and Donald Webber, Jr. many are repeating their roles from the concept album.

In Off-Broadway news, Oscar winner Tilda Swinton will make her NYC stage debut in Man to Man at the Lucille Lortel with previews beginning Feb. 21 and opening Feb. 28. Swinton is currently starring in Man to Man at London's Royal Court Theater in a sold-out run. She originated the role of Ella/Max, a woman who dons her late husband's trousers in 1930s Germany, in the show's UK premiere in 1987. Man to Man will play Scotland and Germany at the Berliner Ensemble before opening in NYC.

Tilda Swinton in Man to Man in London
Credit: Rudiger Glatz

B'way Update: Rhino, Three Days

Tatiana Maslany and John Turturro in
Rhinoceros at ART.
Credit: Hawver and Hall

The rumors were true. As reported in our last Broadway update, Diane Paulus' revival of Eugene Ionesco's Rhinoceros will be coming to the Main Stem. There were rumors that the production, previously seen at the American Repertory Theater in Cambridge, Mass., would be replacing Roundabout Theater Company's revival of The Full Monty on its spring schedule. Roundabout has confirmed that Rhinoceros will stampede into the Todd Haimes Theater for preview performances on April 7 in advance of an April 25 opening. (The Full Monty will be rescheduled.) John Turturro and Tatiana Maslany will repeat their ART performances. Tony winner Tony Shalhoub will take over the role of Jean, played by Paul Giamatti in Cambridge. Jean is the bravura role calling for the actor to transform into the titular horned behemoth for which Zero Mostel won a Tony in the 1960 Broadway production. Ionesco's political allegory concerns a society where conformism demands everyone change into rhinos.

In other Broadway news, the revival of Richard Greenberg's Three Days of Rain has announced dates and a theater. Previews will begin Jan. 20, 2027 at the Longacre Theater with an opening set for March 1 for a limited 16-week run. Tony winner Anna D. Shapiro directs a three person cast consisting of Francois Arnaud (Heated Rivalry), David Corenswet (Superman) and Yvonne Strahovski (The Handmaid's Tale).

Off-B'way Review: Good Time Charlie; Fish; Anon

Ryan Haddad and Jonathan Raviv in
Good Time Charlie.
Credit: Joan Marcus

“There is no plot, but there is a narrative,” exclaims Ryan J. Haddad in his autobiographical play Good Time Charlie, at the Public Theater. Despite the lack of a cohesive storyline, this is a heartwarming, tender love letter to a cherished relative and a celebration of theatre fandom and participation. Haddad is playing a version of himself, and when speaking this line about the plotnessess of his work, he is explaining to the character enacting the title figure, his beloved uncle Charlie, that they are not in a conventional “well-made” play. Instead they are in a tender evocation of Ryan’s childhood, his relationship with Charlie, their mutual love of theater and their contrasting experiences as gay men of different generations. Several playwrights have offered similar strolls down memory lane, most recently Joshua Harmon with We Had a World in which Broadway-loving, gay narrator-protagonist similarly declared “There is no straight line in this play.” Like Harmon’s evocation of his past, Charlie is a combination love letter and excorism of family secrets and buried resentments told in meta-theatrical terms, often directly to the audience.

Haddad has previously explored his background and development as a gay, handicapped Lebanese-American theater artist in solo or semi-solo shows such as Hold Me in the Water and Dark Disabled Stories. Here he expands his canvas to include his whole family, focusing on his uncle (actually a cousin) who introduced him to theater and encouraged him to fully explore his sexual identity. Haddad and Jonathan Raviv as Charlie have a believable bond as the relatives seeking strength and comfort from each other and sharing a joy of the stage.

Ryan Haddad, Tim Bagley, Beth Malone,
Jonathan Raviv, and Michael Cristofer in
Good Time Charlie.
Credit: Joan Marcus

We also meet Charlie’s empathic partner Lou (warm and loving Tim Bagley from Will and Grace), their longtime friend Sheldon (acerbic and tender Michael Cristofer) who runs a revival cinema, Ryan’s supportive lesbian aunt Janice (sturdy Beth Malone), and the parents of both Ryan and Charlie who deal with their offspring’s coming out in vastly different ways. Nael Nacer and Artemis Pebdani double as both sets of elders, differentiating between the two with subtle variations and with the aide of Robert Pickens’ hair and wig design.