Thursday, November 19, 2026

B'way Review: Much Ado About Nothing

Hayley Atwell and Tom Hiddleston
in Much Ado About Nothing.
Credit: Andy Henderson
The biggest party of the year is taking place at the Winter Garden Theater as Jamie Lloyd’s stripped-down, blissed-out take on Shakespeare’s classic battle-of-the-sexes comedy Much Ado About Nothing erupts off the stage and into the audience’s hearts, brains, and loins. As he has with Romeo and Juliet, Sunset Blvd., and A Doll’s House, Lloyd pares down the Bard’s text to its essence, infuses it with a modern sensibility and gives it a fresh, pulsating vitality. His stars Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell, repeating their London performances, play off each other like world-class athletes, launching jibes and jests at each other like tennis balls in a rapid and dizzying volley. Lloyd even pokes fun at their superhero/villain roles in the Marvel Comics film universe, using cardboard cut-outs of their characters Loki and Peggy Carter to satirize their romantic merrymaking. 

The fun starts even before the curtain rises as ushers lead theatergoers in dance moves like the Macarena and the pop-music sound design of Ben and Max Ringham blasts throughout the auditorium. Once the show starts, the ten-member cast bogeys onto Sutra Gilmour’s dance-club set with pink confetti perpetually falling and a huge heart balloon hovering above the action. 


The stage is soon buried in confetti as Hiddleston and Atwell as the reluctant lovers/sparring partners Benedick and Beatrice attack each other and dodge Cupid’s arrows, finally succumbing through deceptions devised by friends and family. Both are brilliant combatants, expertly conveying their mutual magnetic attraction and their heroic efforts to resist. They involve the audience by directly addressing us and satirizing theatrical conventions and their own movie-star pedigrees. Lloyd’s staging is immensely clever, employing surprises, giant animal heads, trapdoors, and Fabian Aloise’s wild choreography, all through a pansexual lens. The lady-in-waiting Margaret is played by non-binary performer Mason Alexander Park who provides commentary through ironic pop songs, crooned with impressive pipes. The villain of the piece, Don John (a reptilian Tim Steed) is cast as a repressed gay man, furious at being forced into a traditionally masculine mold and costumed by Gilmour with pearls and a cashmere sweater. (Gilmour’s designs are gorgeously chic and stylish throughout.)


Hayley Atwell and Tom Hiddleston in
Much Ado About Nothing.
Credit: Andy Henderson
Extraneous characters and subplots have been removed. Gone are the buffoonish constable Dogberry and his retinue of Keystone Cops as well as superfluous relatives and servants. When I read the cast list, I thought “These cuts will never work.” But they do. Shakespeare’s scintillating struggle of wits retains its sparkle and the flashy staging does not distract. The constant confetti störm is not a problem either. The rain of pink ends at the appropriate serious moment when Beatrice’s cousin Hero (vivacious and funny Mara Huf) is falsely accused of being a slut by her deceived intended Claudio (vibrant James Phoon). Forbes Masson lends considerable weight to this mood shift as Leonato, Hero’s disgraced father. His passionate reaction to his daughter’s calamity is heartfelt and shattering, taking the proceedings to another level. Jon Clark’s lighting also aides in the transition to a more somber tone as the twilight party atmosphere gives way a bleak morning-after feel, unforgiving in its harshness. 


In addition to those already cited, the estimable ensemble includes Gerald Kyd’s distinguished silver fox of a Don Pedro, Mika Onyx Johnson’s oily henchman Borachio, and Philip Olagoke’s sage Friar Francis who hides a secret of his own. Along with their colleagues they make up one of the most consistently joyful and exciting Shakespearean companies seen on Broadway in recent memory.


Nov. 19—Jan. 10, 2027. Winter Garden Theater, 1634 Broadway, NYC. Running time: two hours and 20 mins. including intermission. telecharge.com.


Mason Alexander Park (c.) and cast 
in Much Ado About Nothing.
Credit: Andy Henderson


No comments:

Post a Comment